FDA Prosecution under the Park Doctrine
In Park, the FDA sought to prosecute the president of a large, national food store chain for causing interstate food shipments to be exposed to rodent contamination in violation of § 301(k) of the FDCA.2 A jury convicted the company’s president after the court instructed that it could find the president guilty if the jurors concluded he had a “responsible relationship to the issue.” The Court of Appeals, however, overturned the verdict, concluding the company president could not be convicted absent proof that the he was “aware of some wrongdoing.”3 The Supreme Court granted the FDA’s appeal, and reversed the appellate court’s decision, reinstating the trial court’s conviction of the company president. In so holding, the Court held the FDCA imposes upon corporate officers “not only a positive duty to seek out and remedy violations but also, and primarily, a duty to implement measures that will insure that violations will not occur.” Moreover, the Court held, the FDCA “punishes neglect where the law requires care or inaction where it imposes a duty.” These general precepts became known as the Park Doctrine, and it is this doctrine the Department of Justice and FDA have relied upon in the recent prosecutions of corporate officers from companies such as Synthes and Purdue Frederick Co.
In 2011, the FDA published nonbinding criteria the agency considers in recommending Park Doctrine prosecutions. These criteria include: (1) the individual’s position in the company; (2) the individual’s relationship to the violation; and (3) whether the official had the authority to correct or prevent the violation. The FDA also has provided a non-exhaustive list of seven additional factors the agency may consider, including one drawn directly from Park: “whether the violation reflects a pattern of illegal behavior and/or failure to heed prior warnings.”
To minimize the chance of prosecution under the Park Doctrine, it is wise for life-science companies to designate a compliance officer or committee responsible for implementing and updating written policies, procedures, and standards of conduct to which corporate officers must adhere. It is not sufficient for responsible corporate officers to delegate and discharge compliance and oversight; rather, they should take an active role in ensuring a proactive and positive culture of compliance.
1 421 U.S. 658 (1975).
2 Id.
3499 F.2d 839, 842 (4th Cir. 1974).
Lisa Noller, Esq. is a litigation partner with Foley & Lardner LLP.
How Medmarc Can Help
Life sciences and medical technology companies face complex and evolving risks throughout the product lifecycle. Medmarc provides specialized life sciences insurance, medical device insurance, products liability coverage, and risk management expertise to address the unique exposures of the industry. From emerging technologies and clinical trials to products on the market, Medmarc combines decades of life sciences experience with specialized industry knowledge and insurance solutions.
Explore Medmarc's insurance solutions to learn more about our capabilities, and talk with your insurance broker about your organization’s evolving risks and insurance considerations.
Phone: 888-633-6272
Copyright © 2026 - Medmarc
Medmarc is a proud member of TDC Specialty. TDC Specialty is the marketing name for the specialty insurance operations and services of The Doctors Company and its subsidiaries and affiliated companies, including TDC Specialty Underwriters, Inc., TDC Specialty Insurance Company, TDC National Assurance Company, Healthcare Risk Advisors, Inc., Hospitals Insurance Company, Inc., ProAssurance Specialty Insurance Company, NORCAL Specialty Insurance Company, and Medmarc Casualty Insurance Company. All products and services are written or provided by subsidiaries or affiliates of The Doctors Company. The Doctors Company does not underwrite excess and surplus lines insurance. Certain coverages may be provided through surplus lines insurance subsidiaries of The Doctors Company through licensed surplus lines brokers. Coverages may be underwritten by TDC Specialty Insurance Company, TDC National Assurance Company, Hospitals Insurance Company, Inc., ProAssurance Specialty Insurance Company, NORCAL Specialty Insurance Company, or Medmarc Casualty Insurance Company. Product summaries are for informational purposes only. Coverage is subject to the language of the policy as actually issued. Coverage, policy terms, and availability may vary by state.
TDC Specialty Underwriters, Inc., is based and domiciled in Connecticut; in California d/b/a Insurance City Solutions (license #0L85833) and in New York, d/b/a TDC Specialty Underwriters Services. Healthcare Risk Advisors, Inc., is based and domiciled in New York.
