Selecting Employee Witnesses

Published by Jim Hughey III

Question: We are a small manufacturer of medical devices and have just been served with our first lawsuit. We have been asked by appointed counsel to select someone within our company to respond to and provide evidence for the case. What should we consider when making the selection?

Answer: The short answer is "it depends". Considerations include the specific allegations in the legal Complaint filed by the plaintiff, your organizational structure and the personnel within your company. Generally speaking, you should engage those individuals within the company who are most familiar with those aspects of the product challenged in the Complaint, such as its design, manufacture or regulatory approval. While many companies limit their selection to managers, you should consider involving “front line” employees whose work for the company brings them closest to the aspects of the product which are at issue.

When the lawsuit progresses to the point where documents and testimony must be provided, you need to provide the most accurate and persuasive information possible and be consistent in your responses. So, identify the key employees as soon as possible and before you respond to document requests or provide a witness to testify. To the extent possible, be consistent in using the same individual(s) to certify answers to interrogatories, review document productions, and give testimony in the case. Ask hard questions and follow up to make sure you find all pertinent facts. And, most of all, be sure to consult with your attorney on all witness decisions.

Last updated on April 5, 2023

For additional resources, contact the Marketing department

Phone: 888-633-6272

TDC Specialty is the marketing name for the specialty insurance operations and services of The Doctors Company and its subsidiaries and affiliated companies, including TDC Specialty Underwriters, Inc., TDC Specialty Insurance Company, TDC National Assurance Company, Healthcare Risk Advisors, Inc., Hospitals Insurance Company, Inc., ProAssurance Specialty Insurance Company, and Medmarc Casualty Insurance Company. All products and services are written or provided by subsidiaries or affiliates of The Doctors Company. The Doctors Company does not underwrite excess and surplus lines insurance. Certain coverages may be provided through surplus lines insurance subsidiaries of The Doctors Company through licensed surplus lines brokers. Coverages may be underwritten by TDC Specialty Insurance Company, TDC National Assurance Company, Hospitals Insurance Company, Inc., ProAssurance Specialty Insurance Company or Medmarc Casualty Insurance Company, all wholly owned subsidiaries of The Doctors Company. Product summaries are for informational purposes only. Coverage is subject to the language of the policy as actually issued. Coverage, policy terms, and availability may vary by state.

TDC Specialty Underwriters, Inc., is based and domiciled in Connecticut; in California d/b/a Insurance City Solutions (license #0L85833) and in New York, d/b/a TDC Specialty Underwriters Services. Healthcare Risk Advisors, Inc., is based and domiciled in New York.

Back to Blog